Sunday, September 15, 2013
Yossi Beilin: PM Rabin did not consult with security or intelligence officials over Oslo
Yossi Beilin: PM Rabin did not consult with security or intelligence
officials over Oslo
Dr. Aaron Lerner Date: 15 August 2013
Yossi Beilin said in a live interview on Israel Radio broadcast this morning
on Israel Radio Reshet Bet (Hakol Diburim) that he carried out the
negotiations with the PLO that lead to the Oslo Agreements without the
authorization or knowledge of Prime Minister Yitzchak Rabin. PM Rabin was
only made aware of the talks at the end of February 1993 after the second
round of talks concluded with a working paper.
Beilin said that from the time that PM Rabin was aware of the talks until
their conclusion, PM Rabin opted not to consult with any security or
intelligence officials. The security and intelligence officials were not
advised of the existence of the talks.
Beilin explained that Foreign Minister Shimon Peres was also kept out of the
loop because PM Rabin had insisted that FM Peres have no involvement in
negotiations with the Arabs.
Excerpts from: Yossi Beilin - Interview by Ari Shavit "Yossi removes his
glasses" Haaretz Magazine, March 7, 1997
[Translation by IMRA]
Shavit: When you entered the Oslo process, Rabin Peres and you, was it clear
to you that this was going to a Palestinian state?
Beilin: No. It is very interesting to note that the talks of the soul
regarding "where will this process lead" took place only between the sides,
not within them.within the Labor party and within the government and within
the negotiating team I don't recall any real and serious discussion of the
Shavit: I don't understand. In 1992 you were elected to the government. In
1993 you created the Oslo process. At no stage did you ask yourselves where
this all was leading to?
Shavit: You never spoke with Rabin about the significance of Oslo in the
Shavit: And with Peres?
Beilin: I also never spoke with Peres about it.
Shavit: That's to say that we are going to an historic process that is
second to none in its drama and at no stage you don't say "wait a moment,
let's think about this", let's check where we are basically going?
Beilin: By Rabin, avoidance of the final arrangement was a kind of policy.
He pushed it off. After he died I sat with Leah Rabin and I said to her -
if someone could have known what final arrangement Rabin had in mind it's
only you. She told me - "Look, I can't tell you. He was very pragmatic,
hated to deal with what will be in many more years. He thought about what
will be now, very soon. To the best of my knowledge he did not have a very
clear picture of what the final arrangement would be"
Rabin thought that things would develop, saw something instrumental like
that, some autonomy that might become a state and might not. He did not
have a clear picture.
Shavit: The question that must be raised is if the decisions of Oslo were
made at all in a rational process?
Beilin: In general there aren't rational processes. Rationality, at the
end, is almost always rationalizing. When you look at these kinds of
processes you find that almost always the things happen out of internal
feelings of the participants that they are doing the right thing. Out of
their emotions and intuition and personal experience.
Shavit: have you considered at times, that maybe, because of 1948, the
complications of the dispute make it unsolvable?
Beilin: Yes. It occurs to me. But I immediately utterly rejects it. I see
myself as an absolute rationalist and I want to live a rational world. I
very much want to live in a world in which there is a solution to our
existential problems that is possible. I have no proof that this is indeed
the situation. This is like being an optimist. Is an optimist convinced
that the pessimist is always wrong? No. He simply convinces himself that
things will be good. That it will be OK. And then he also does everything
in order to insure that he is right. That's the way I am.
I simply am not prepared to live in a world in which things cannot be
Dr. Aaron Lerner, Director IMRA (Independent Media Review & Analysis)
(Mail POB 982 Kfar Sava) Tel 972-9-7604719/Fax 972-3-7255730
INTERNET ADDRESS: email@example.com Website: http://www.imra.org.il
IMRA - Independent Media Review and Analysis
For free regular subscription:
Subscribe at no charge: firstname.lastname@example.org
For free daily digest subscription:
Subscribe at no charge: email@example.com
For a copy of all reports distributed for a given day please send a
firstname.lastname@example.org email@example.com firstname.lastname@example.org