October 15, 2013
How Jewish should Israel be? Why does the West
recognize that democracy must be accommodated to Arabic culture world
over, but not to Judaism in Israel? A thought provoking analysis based
on Prof. Paul Eidelberg's "Jewish Statesmanship".
The author is a retired attorney and the editor of Israpundit. In 2009 he made aliya and is
now living in Jerusalem.
PM Netanyahu has made it clearer than ever, that the PA must
recognize “Israel as the national homeland of the Jewish People.” But
Israel must decide how Jewish it wants to be.
Most Israeli Jews
embrace the mantra that Israel should be both democratic and Jewish but
pay little attention to whether the two ideas are compatible. The left
in Israel say that being democratic should not be compromised and
Israel’s High Court agrees with it. The Right in Israel think otherwise,
that being Jewish should take precedence over being democratic where
the two are in conflict and they want the Knesset to pass the necessary
laws to make it so.
Israel’s Justice Minister, Tziporah Livni,
recently said to “those who want to claim that the power of the majority
in the Knesset is greater than the power ?of the courts,” that “[The]
Knesset operates according to the principle of the majority, but the job
of the Supreme Court is to ensure that the Knesset abides by the values
of justice, and therefore, one needs to defend it.”