April 5, 2013
This is the functional equivalent of agreeing not to swing the wrecking ball after you've set the house on fire.
Last summer, Nathan Thrall of the International Crisis Group predicted - and justified - the emergence of a "third intifada" in the New York Times, blaming Israel for not reaching a deal with Abbas. It was odd timing because by summer 2012, Abbas had his hands full with angry Palestinians protesting just about everything except Israel. A wave of public discontent through the fall and into 2013 has been focused on police brutality, the cost of living, government-imposed austerity measures, and Abbas himself. Salam Fayyed, the unelected prime minister and a U.S. ally, was the focus of unhappiness over limited economic prospects. Pro-Abbas gangs have assaulted protesters, and journalists have been arrested and beaten. Palestinian officials even cracked down on Western activists supporting the protesters. "The involvement of Western nationals in protests against the Palestinian Authority is completely unacceptable," one official said. "We will be forced to cut off all ties with non-Palestinians who incite against the Palestinian leadership."
At some point, it was necessary for Abbas to turn that public anger away from his own shortcomings and toward Israel. After scaling back security cooperation with the IDF, in December, the PA authorized Friday post-mosque pro-Hamas rallies near IDF checkpoints in the West Bank. The rallies predictably turned into skirmishes. Tension between the IDF, Israel border police, and Palestinians has continued to escalate; Palestinians have been injured and Palestinian rock throwers left an Israeli infant in critical condition.
Back in January, the biggest fight was among Palestinian factions in the Balata refugee camp on the West Bank. According to The Times of Israel, "The PA security forces arrived… in the early morning to arrest [two men], leaders in Fatah's al-Aqsa Martyr's Brigades, who were caught on camera by Israel's Channel 2 TV station on Thursday parading their weapons around the camp and firing into the air. They were protesting ill treatment by the PA." The arrest failed when camp residents burned tires to block the entrance. Around the same time, shots were fired at the Jenin governor – whose predecessor died of a heart attack after shots were fired at his home. There were protests in Ramallah over the PA's failure to pay salaries and over a PA decision not to collect money owed by refugee camp residents to the electric company (non-refugees wanted the payment amnesty, too).
So Abbas has been pouring anti-Israel gasoline on the passions to try to preserve his rule.
specifically calling for suicide bombers (futile, since the security
fence makes it almost impossible for them to reach their targets) Fatah
honored a 2002 suicide bomber
on its Facebook page. "The name of Wafa Idris is still a lesson that
terrifies the Jews." "At least 2,000 Palestinians participated in the
symbolic funeral (this month) marched for Wafa Idris behind an empty
wooden coffin… draped in the Palestinian flag." They "called 'Wafa is a
hero' while armed men fired in the air to salute Wafa."
- In late March, Fatah honored Um Nadal,
mother of three sons: one invented the Qassam rocket (he was killed
when one went off prematurely), one was a suicide bomber and one was
killed with Hamas. Um Nadal told Palestinian TV that the day her son
went to a school in Jerusalem and killed five students was "the best day
of my life. I feel that our Lord is pleased with me, because I am
offering something [my son] for Him. I wish to sacrifice more [sons] for
Allah's forgiveness, and for the flag [of Islam]."
- Ahlam al Tamimi, one of the organizers of the Sbarro Pizzaria bombing in Jerusalem,
gave an interview widely disseminated in the PA territories. "You know
how many casualties there were? This was made possible by Allah. Do you
want me to denounce what I did? That's out of the question. I would do
it again today, and in the same manner." The casualties included 15
killed and over 130 wounded, including eight children, six members of a
single family, a pregnant woman and another woman who was left in a
Abbas got the conflagration he sought. The death of Maysara Abu Hamdiya – complete with a phony picture purporting to show his arm handcuffed to a hospital bed, and lies about his lack of treatment for cancer – precipitated angry demonstrations in the West Bank, and two young men throwing firebombs at an Israeli police post have been killed. The riots and demonstrations will likely escalate, and an Israeli response is assured. Whether Abbas can stage-manage the demonstrations is less assured.
The tightrope Abbas walks, between Palestinians already unhappy with him for social, political and economic reasons, and those who will be more unhappy if he agrees to Israel's basic requirements for "end of conflict, end of claims," is one largely of his own making. The chances of success for the Kerry mission are dim – it will be remarkable if he can escape without having the Palestinian house collapse around him.
Shoshana Bryen is Senior Director of The Jewish Policy Center.